Dermatology · USMLE Step 1

Pemphigus vulgaris vs bullous pemphigoid: one split, every difference

Pemphigus vulgaris and bullous pemphigoid compared: desmosomes vs hemidesmosomes, flaccid vs tense blisters, Nikolsky sign, immunofluorescence patterns, triggers and treatment, with USMLE-style questions.

By MedNotes Editorial TeamUpdated 6 min read

Pemphigus vulgaris and bullous pemphigoid are the two autoimmune blistering diseases every exam asks about. Their names are almost the same, but they attack different structures at different depths of the skin, and almost every difference between them follows from that one fact: where the skin splits.

Skin layers: in pemphigus vulgaris the split is inside the epidermis just above the basal layer, giving flaccid blisters; in bullous pemphigoid the whole epidermis lifts at the basement membrane, giving tense blisters
Figure 1. The level of the split explains the blister: a thin roof in pemphigus, the whole epidermis in pemphigoid.

Pemphigus vulgaris

IgG autoantibodies against desmoglein 3 (and often desmoglein 1) break the desmosomes that hold keratinocytes together, so the cells fall apart (acantholysis) just above the basal layer. The basal cells stay stuck to the basement membrane like a row of tombstones. Patients are usually 40 to 60. Painful mouth erosions often come first, sometimes months before the skin, followed by flaccid blisters that break and leave raw, painful erosions. The Nikolsky sign is positive. Untreated, it is fatal from fluid loss and infection. See the free pemphigus vulgaris flowchart.

Bullous pemphigoid

IgG against the hemidesmosome proteins BP180 (type XVII collagen) and BP230 activates complement and draws in eosinophils, whose enzymes cut the anchors. The whole epidermis lifts, so the blisters are tense and rarely break. It affects people over 70, starts with weeks of itch and urticarial plaques, rarely involves the mouth and heals without scarring. Drugs can trigger it, especially DPP-4 inhibitors (gliptins) and loop diuretics, and it is linked with dementia and Parkinson disease.

Direct immunofluorescence: pemphigus shows IgG outlining every keratinocyte in a fishnet pattern; bullous pemphigoid shows a single bright line of IgG and C3 along the basement membrane
Figure 2. Direct immunofluorescence of skin next to a blister settles the diagnosis.

Side by side

Pemphigus vulgaris compared with bullous pemphigoid
Pemphigus vulgarisBullous pemphigoid
TargetDesmoglein 3 (and 1): desmosomesBP180 and BP230: hemidesmosomes
SplitIntraepidermal (suprabasal)Subepidermal
BlistersFlaccid, break into erosionsTense, intact
Nikolsky signPositiveNegative
MouthAlmost always, often firstUncommon and mild
Age40–60Over 70
BiopsyAcantholysis, row of tombstonesSubepidermal blister with eosinophils
ImmunofluorescenceIntercellular IgG (fishnet)Linear IgG and C3 at the basement membrane
First-line treatmentRituximab with systemic steroidsSuperpotent topical steroid (clobetasol)

Two more blistering diseases to know

  • Dermatitis herpetiformis: intensely itchy grouped vesicles on the elbows, knees and buttocks, linked to celiac disease. Granular IgA in the dermal papillae. Treat with dapsone and a gluten-free diet.
  • Pemphigus foliaceus: antibodies to desmoglein 1 only, so the split is high (just under the stratum corneum): crusted scaly erosions on the face and trunk, no mouth involvement.

Practice questions

Question 1DermatologyPemphigus vulgaris

A 52-year-old woman has had painful mouth ulcers for 2 months. She now has flaccid blisters on her trunk that rupture easily, leaving raw erosions. Gentle pressure on normal-looking skin next to a blister makes the epidermis slide off. Antibodies against which structure are responsible?

Question 2DermatologyBullous pemphigoid

An 81-year-old man with type 2 diabetes treated with sitagliptin has had months of itching and now has large tense blisters on his thighs and abdomen. His mouth is normal and the Nikolsky sign is negative. A perilesional biopsy is sent for direct immunofluorescence. What will it most likely show?

Question 3DermatologyTreatment of pemphigus

A 50-year-old man has confirmed pemphigus vulgaris with extensive skin and mouth erosions. He is started on oral prednisone. Which additional treatment best induces long-term remission and reduces his steroid dose?

Go deeper in the Knowledge Hub: autoimmune blistering diseases, bullous pemphigoid and blistering skin diseases. The free pemphigus vulgaris flowchart shows the disease from cause to treatment.

About this article. Written and checked by the MedNotes team, who build the USMLE Prep question bank, notes and Knowledge Hub. It is for exam study only and is not medical advice; see our medical disclaimer. Spotted an error? Tell us.